28 October 2022

The False Dilemma of the 2022 Election

Albert Mohler and other Evangelicals are right, we as Christians cannot vote for Democrats. Amen. And they go further and suggest those that do so fall under condemnation. Amen to that as well.


But if they can't say the same about the GOP then they're not representing a New Testament position. They're simply partisans and operatives for a political faction.

The GOP is just as wicked, bankrupt, and anti-Christian as the Democrats are.

In fact the entire system is. Don't support it by voting.

If you don't vote you can't complain.

I used to think that way but it's backwards.

If you vote, you can't complain because if you believe in the system you have to abide by the results and (if you're a true citizen) support the democratic choice and the country – right or wrong. That's un-Christian, a compromised allegiance. I don't oppose the government as the powers that be are ordained by God – but I don't support it either, regardless of the political party in charge.

In addition to its well established record of mammonism and militarism, the GOP's more recent embrace of shameless deception, outright lies, and political violence, signifies a hard turn toward authoritarianism and fascism – and the party is clearly aligning with fascists beyond its borders. In some instances this Far-Right anti-democratic turn is being obscured or given cover by claims that the American democratic system only works in a Christian context. At this point these apologists for political scheming and violence usually pull out some quotes from a few select Founding Fathers that seemingly support this argument.

As such, since the society has lost its 'Christian' consensus, they believe that democracy can no longer be trusted, and in order to recapture America they can legitimately (as patriots) appeal to anti-Constitutional ideas and authoritarian tactics – even raw violence. These arguments expose the true ugliness and unethical nature of the 1776 argument for rebellion – a position no Christian should have supported then or now.

But guess what? That's not what the founding documents say. They do not claim to function within the context of a Christian consensus (nor require it) and in fact (in good Enlightenment Classical Liberal fashion) the documents explicitly reject the heritage of Christendom. The United States was the first Western nation established since the times of Constantine, Theodosius, and Charlemagne to not establish rule on the basis of the grace of God, or in His Name and authority. No, the USA was and is an Enlightenment project rooted in Liberalism and questions of rights and social contract. It's not Christian and wasn't meant to be. The Founders were turning their back on a Christian political order. The old order of Christendom wasn't Christian either but that's beside the point.

The claims made in the Declaration and Constitution are supposedly 'self-evident' and thus universal and so if you don't believe they're universal (applicable in all places and at all times) then you're not a patriot in the ideological mold of the Founders. I'm not and don't claim to be. I oppose and reject the system and its very premise. That said, while I live under it (due to historical circumstance) I won't vote, appeal to it for justice, support its wars, or endorse its ideals. I obey laws (even unjust ones) and thus honour those who make and enforce them, and pay taxes – as long as they don't cause me to directly sin or participate in sin. As such, I embrace second-class citizenship or to put it differently I live as a subject not a citizen.

The New Testament has no concept of 'rights' and is not interested in pursuing them – and neither am I. We're called not to dominion or the exercise of Enlightenment-conceived rights, but to providential obedience and if need be suffering. Such suffering may be cultural and economic or at times it can be violent.

I'm productive and have raised my children to be the same. That's all they're getting out of me. I won't fly the flag or pledge allegiance to it. I won't serve on a jury but nor do I want one – or the courts, or the police. I understand that society will utilise these mechanisms and they serve a purpose in this present evil age, but I have no use for them and will not help to perpetuate them. Let the dead bury their dead. Let them pursue their Babel project. I am a citizen of Zion. Our pilgrim calling vis-à-vis the culture is prophetic (little 'p') and ambassadorial but we're not here to transform or redeem things that are cursed and doomed. That's what the New Testament says. Our focus is on the Church and we glorify God to that end – by condemning the world and proclaiming its doom, by worshipping God in defiance of the principalities and powers, and in sharing the gospel message of hope and redemption.

But I say to those who believe in the system and think it is, was, or has to be Christian – and then turn to authoritarianism, deceit, and violence – your actions are not only unbiblical, you're even un-American in your thinking. You're living out a contradiction in terms of ideology and ethics – as were the Founders I might add.

The polity of the country is mixed. The federal government is secular in origin, and yet many of the states (erroneously) had some kind of Christian establishment or sanction. This doesn't make it right. It must be evaluated. On Biblical grounds it must be rejected and in terms of the Federal government, the Constitutional system which emerged was in a state of contradiction on these points and many others. It was a flawed system and within a century collapsed into civil war. The victors retained the forms but they were added to – amendments which fundamentally changed the polity at certain points, and created even more internal contradictions. Regardless, a new Federal order emerged and so in many respects these debates are pointless and are rarely able to stay on track. The truth is the fundamental original flaws have never been resolved nor has the post-Civil War settlement. And from a Christian standpoint these issues have no resolution as the system is incompatible with the gospel and Kingdom of Jesus Christ.

America is not a Christian country. There's no such thing. The very notion is an oxymoron. You can attach the name of Christ to the godless Constitution (and a lot of other things) but that doesn't make it Christian. It just adds to the confusion and condemnation of the country and its mammon-worshiping violent society. Christians should oppose such measures and we should insist the 'In God We Trust' blasphemy be removed from the currency. In any case it's not the God of Scripture and so it's nothing Christians should endorse or celebrate.

The system is wicked in its fundamental ideology, and the mammon driven society it produced. Don't let your thinking be shaped by false political binaries and scam operatives who are simply trying to manipulate you by means of false appeals, fear tactics, and disingenuous guilt.

If you're a Christian you have no business voting in an election that has nothing to do with us. The Republican Party isn't pro-life and its leaders are not godly. They are creatures of the world and enslaved to its lusts. The Christians in government are self-deceived frauds and in many cases functional apostates. They are not to be elevated or emulated but pitied. The Church only corrupts itself when it forms such alliances and then strengthens the hands of these evildoers.

The appeal is made that we need to change the world, a point accentuated by the Neo-Evangelical movement which emerged in the late 1940's – a movement that now dominates the entire spectrum of American and even (to some extent) global Christianity. In the aftermath of World War II, men like Billy Graham wanted to dispense with Fundamentalist separatism and encourage the Church to hold a position of respect in society and to be influential. Seventy-five years later the result is all too clear. They did not change the world but they did invite the world into the Church and the effect has been profound and (in terms of their misguided and unbiblical movement) fatal. The tragedy has been compounded by the fact that they continue to swallow up and encompass numerous groups and movements within the wider sphere of both national and international Protestantism and even now are in the process of corrupting these bodies and bringing them down to share in the same doom that awaits American Evangelicalism.

When these false teachers speak on the radio, turn it off. When dominionism and pseudo-Christian politics are preached from the pulpit, it's time to think about leaving.