Iain Murray's 'The Invitation System' rightly condemns the
Altar Call for its tactics of coercion and manipulation, for making emotional
appeals that lack substance. As an unbiblical method it creates a false
conversion and ultimately does more harm to the hearer than if they had never
heard the gospel in the first place.
The Altar Call is built on a spurious theological foundation.
Misunderstanding conversion, the gospel, sin, repentance and salvation it is a
dangerous caricature of the true gospel invitation to heartfelt repentance and brokenness.
At this point I heartily agree with Murray, who condemns the
theology of Charles Finney as well as those who came after him and took up his
mantle and legacy. This theology gave us Moody, Sunday, Graham and it could be
argued was re-cast once more in the Seeker movement. These men have done irreparable
harm to the cause of Christ.
And yet, for all that, in another form this is the very
theology advocated by Murray.
How so?