27 June 2023

The Ripples of Evangelical Collapse

Looking at a social media photo of members of our wider family circle (a network of relations connected by marriage) – I'm struck once again by the rapid fall of American Evangelicalism. The photo is of a mother, her daughters and their 'spouses'. One of the daughters stands boldly and unashamedly with another woman.


I've talked about this before but in this case I refer to a good Christian Evangelical family that I've known peripherally for many years – often appearing at the same larger family gatherings. The father has since died of cancer and their two daughters have lost their way. One has married a pagan man and yet apparently retains some kind of Christian profession – never challenged for her sinful choice. And the other has turned lesbian.

Now it's one thing to say to a wayward child 'my door is always open' and to invite them into the home – without the homosexual partner. As such it's likely that in many cases the son or daughter will then refuse taking offense. So be it, that's their choice. But to invite them into your home with their sinful paramours, let them stay in your house (sharing a bedroom) and then include them in a big family photo that is disseminated to friends and family – what is that but an endorsement? It's not a tacit approval but an explicit statement of acceptance.

The mother also travels to where the lesbians live and stays with them in their house – another sign of approval an acceptance.

How is this helping your wayward child that has fallen into apostasy? Again, we're not speaking of a pagan child fallen into perversity, but a young Christian woman that has fallen from grace. There has to be accountability according to the Scriptures.

But as with many middle class American parents, the relationship with the child is placed over and above the relationship with Christ – something the Scriptures warn against. The polarity and antithesis created by the gospel that Christ insists will break families apart is being circumvented by an apostate Church that won't hold anyone to account.

Did they confront and discipline the daughter who married the pagan? No.

Did they confront and discipline the daughter who turned lesbian? No. They tepidly challenged the daughter but nothing happened and the challenge (as as I know) came only from a pastor family member, not an officer in the congregation her family is part of.

Did they challenge the mother and subject her to discipline and rebuke for posting this photo on social media – a post that clearly endorses the arrangement? Of course not.

Once again as we've witnessed these scenarios among family, friends, and the larger church – I am driven to ask a question. What would it take for you to make a stand? Is there anything that would drive you to draw a line and refuse to compromise?

I'm afraid for many Evangelicals the answer is 'no'.

I can only think of one exception and that's politics. I think in some cases if one of your children took a hard turn to the Left or somehow was actively involved in anti-military or some kind of anti-patriotic activism – that might actually drive some of these people to take a firm stand.

This is apostasy pure and simple.

These folks are part of the Christian and Missionary Alliance which just recently voted to ordain women. Given the culture at work within American Evangelicalism does this surprise anyone? Do you think if their church ends up with a woman as pastor will they leave? Will they even be upset? Why would they? Nothing else matters it would seem but tranquility, riches, and the illusion of contentment.

It is striking to me to observe with these parents (and I can easily think of others) that are so desperate to keep the peace with their children they are willing to let them drift off into apostasy and hell-fire. Apparently nothing is worse than not being able to have those happy family gatherings. It is literally short-sighted with a selfish eye only on this world even while ignoring eternity. How is this loving your children?

In some cases their weakened understanding of the gospel can retain a view that these people are Christians (backslid perhaps) – despite New Testament evidence to the contrary.

In other cases I'm left wondering how much these people really believe themselves? Their faith has been choked by riches and the cares of this world and they have demonstrated that they fall under the condemnation of verses such as Matthew 10.37 – he that loveth son or daughter more than me is not worthy of me. Luke 14.26 also speaks to this saying – If any man come to me and hate not his father, and mother, and wife, and children, and brethren, and sisters, yea, and his own life also, he cannot be my disciple.

These verses generate occasional confusion for some as they mistakenly believe there is an imperative to hate. That of course misses the point. It's a (partly) hyperbolic comparison and contrast with one's call to love Christ and if that means sundering these family ties – then that's what we're called to do. We don't have to actively break them but in following Christ they will be nevertheless broken – if we're faithful.

Evangelicalism's cheap grace gospel downplays or eliminates these warnings concerning the nature of saving faith and explains away all imperatives and obligations. We are not saved by works but a faith that does not produce trust and obedience (certainly flawed, but a qualitative difference in one's life, as well as an ongoing drive to repentance and some sign of sanctification or regeneration), then that person should not be allowed to continue in their presumption. The problem all too often is with the Church. The Word is not faithfully preached. If it was, this wayward mother would either be spurred to action with her daughters or she would leave and find someplace else to have her ears tickled – or maybe just walk away from the faith altogether. But nothing happens because the gospel is misunderstood (in the name of grace) and the churches are corrupt institutions primarily focused on sustaining themselves financially and driving away people and potentially whole families is bad for business.

This is the end result – unchallenged apostasy that spreads like a canker and rots the church from within. The pastors go on preaching 'peace, peace', all is well, God is with us, blessing us in our wealth and power – even while the False Church and the bestial powers it has aligned with fall under judgment – which produces more apostasy. This happened during the Middle Ages.

It's an interesting if tragic cycle and get ready for it's about to intensify. Between cultural compromise such as this and the growing embrace of radicalism, Christians are going to find it harder and harder to meet in conventional church settings – unless they simply close their eyes.