01 November 2026

George Marsden's Study of Fundamentalism and American Culture (1870-1925)

It's a resource I keep returning to year after year. In 1980, George Marsden and Oxford University Press published Fundamentalism and American Culture - The Shaping of Twentieth-Century Evangelicalism 1870-1925. 

This work traces the reaction to modernism within Protestantism during the 19th century. Rising from Millenarian movements and the revivalist heritage, Marsden deals with Fundamentalism by touching on figures from Finney to Moody, the theologians of Princeton, and the rise of Dispensational Theology which would come to dominate the Evangelical movement.

There are intellectual clashes taking place during this time with the rise of science and industry. In some instances it's a case of rural America clashing with the new urban culture and outlook. Scottish Common Sense Realism also plays a significant role as Marsden lays out the 'Baconian' mindset in emergent Fundamentalism - seemingly at odds with its perceived anti-intellectualism. Indeed, more contemporary assessments have pointed out the irony that while Fundamentalism has tended to be anti-intellectual, it's basic epistemology is actually deeply rooted in Enlightenment categories. A case can be made that it was a movement born to emerge in the unique context of 19th century America.

As many will know the name 'Fundamentalism' arises from a series of books published with the financial backing of Lyman Stewart, an oil man connected to the rise of Unocal. He used his wealth to finance and distribute the books and played a critical role in the founding of the Bible Institute of Los Angeles, now BIOLA University. The original 12-volume set (published 1910-1915) was an attempt to draw some boundaries around basic essentials of the Christian faith which were increasingly under attack from Liberal theologians who had in turn become quite influential across the board in terms of denominational bureaucracies and institutions of higher learning. The Bible and historic teachings were under attack, and in the disorganised world of early 20th century Evangelicalism, it was an attempt to establish a baseline, a standard by which to judge and discern what was Christianity and what wasn't. A decade later the Confessionalist Presbyterian J Gresham Machen (1881-1937) would publish 'Christianity and Liberalism' persuasively arguing that Liberal Christianity is in fact another religion entirely rooted in Enlightenment epistemology. It utilizes the historic Christian lexicon but redefines the meanings of doctrines and fills them with alien humanist content. Machen would come into conflict with the leadership at Princeton Seminary, leading him to withdraw and form Westminster Seminary in nearby Pennsylvania. A few years later after a battle over liberal theology and missions boards, he was run out of the PCUSA and would go on to form a new denomination in 1936 - a Confessional body that would shortly thereafter become known as the Orthodox Presbyterian Church (OPC).

Marsden helps to explain how figures like Machen were tangentially connected to Fundamentalism without being Fundamentalists or sharing in their (what was tantamount to) reductionist approach to orthodox Christianity. In addition to rejecting their Biblicism, he was also less than keen on their separatist proclivities which also frequently strayed into legalism. Even Machen's faction would experience some tensions with Fundamentalism as the movement penetrated virtually all denominations. This tendency along with Dispensational theology would lead to a lot of divisions and debates. And even today there are some tiny Fundamentalist Presbyterian groups such as the Bible Presbyterians and (from the British context) the Free Presbyterians. The latter group has a completely different pedigree but by the mid-20th century was in contact with American Fundamentalist circles and Bob Jones University in particular.

With regard to Biblicism, the term has engendered a great deal of confusion as has the corollary claim of Sola Scriptura. I have long argued that many groups which claim these categories and/or use them to criticize others in fact do not hold to them with any kind of consistency. In most cases Biblical authority is accompanied by other commitments or held only partially with true authority limited to only certain areas of doctrinal formation or the regulation of the Christian life.

The year 1925 is significant because of the Scopes Trial in Dayton, Tennessee. While William Jennings Bryan was a less than apt representative of the Fundamentalist view (and by some measures not even a Fundamentalist) he did represent a large section of Midwestern, Southern, or even simply rural American Christian sensibility. Fundamentalism has never been monolithic but it probably became more so in the post-war period.

Fundamentalism relies on a separatist ethos that at one time was far more pronounced. Even today when I visit such churches on the rare occasion - the few that are left, I'm struck by how much things have 'slipped' so to speak. These groups used to be far more rigid when it came to notions of dress and deportment. At this point they're simply trying to survive and so the bar has been lowered. I've witnessed the same struggles with Wesleyan-Holiness circles and this has (in their case) led to schism over dress standards and the like.

Eclipsed by the rise of post-war Evangelicalism in the late 1940's, Fundamentalism has actually been in decline. This discussion is confused by cultural commentary and media coverage that often equates Evangelical figures and movements with Fundamentalism. Sometimes there are shared doctrines but the general tone and tenor, the posture, and the overall ecclesiastical and cultural framework of Fundamentalism is quite different. Fundamentalists often distanced themselves from figures like Billy Graham and even openly criticised him. But again, this too is confused when one considers someone like the late Jerry Falwell who had more Fundamentalist roots and exuded something of its style - but he changed and become one of the figureheads of modern Evangelicalism. His Moral Majority project was Evangelical through-and-through and represented a break with the entire ethos of value system of Fundamentalism. And yet he was successful and that's part of the story - the shift of Fundamentalist churches away from their separatist roots into the mainstream Evangelical movement. Their style and ethos changed and in the 1990's and early 2000's many in the course of fighting the 'Worship Wars' took on Evangelical characteristics and ecclesiology, basically becoming Evangelical. That's how they survived in terms of numbers and continuity with regard to a building. Those that refused have suffered over the past thirty years. I've seen many close their doors and the few that remain are on life support - with 10-15 people on a Sunday morning, most of whom are elderly. They still have their copies of 'Sword of the Lord' and some Chick tracts on the back table, but there's not much life left in them.

I've written before about my own experience and that of my wife. Though we grew up thousands of miles apart we both were reared in the context of this very Fundamentalist-Evangelical transition where the tensions between the two were acutely felt. It's something we talk about quite often and in both our cases, these were circles we would abandon in young adulthood. For my wife (raised in the GARBC), a general unease and exposure to new ideas at an Evangelical college prompted some exploration, and through the influence of friends (common friends it turned out) she landed in the Orthodox Presbyterian Church. For my part, I was never fully assimilated into the Church. After haphazard and irregular Fundamentalist attendance while growing up and after having spent two different spells in Christian schools, as a teenager I became increasingly disinterested in and even at times hostile to Christianity. I rejected baptism and wasn't interested. Broken and spiritually destitute, in my early 20's, I returned to the Scriptures afresh and through some influence of extended family members started reading some Reformed authors such as Pink and Schaeffer. By God's Providence I came into contact with some other young Calvinists while overseas and this would lead me (for many years) solidly into the Reformed camp and eventually to the OPC and PCA - as well as marriage. Since that time we have moved away from Confessional Reformed Christianity - though it seems as if it's never far away. We cannot help but interact with it and though more distant - the Fundamentalist sphere as well.

This in part probably explains my personal fascination with Marsden's narrative - simply because it helps to explain so much of the context for my upbringing and experience in the Church and in connection with what was going on in private Christian schools which were really just emerging at the time.

Marsden necessarily traces out the rise of Liberal Theology - though he doesn't spend a great deal of time explaining its roots, but rather its presence in American thought. As such we encounter the liberal figures that emerged in the wake of the American Civil War period all the way up to Harry Emerson Fosdick who preached the famous sermon 'Shall the Fundamentalists Win?' in 1922 at a Presbyterian Church in Greenwich village. Fosdick was praised by Martin Luther King Jr. as 'the greatest preacher of this century'. The Rockefeller-funded and rather imposing Riverside Church on the Upper West Side (near Union Theological Seminary, Columbia, and Grant's Tomb) continues to be associated with Fosdick (who pastored there from 1930-1946) and the theological rejection of Fundamentalism. It's well worth just walking around those blocks of the Upper West Side and reflecting on the period and the conflict.

Dwight Moody is a seminal figure in the rise of Fundamentalism. Like Billy Graham two generations later he was able to bring together various strands and movements into a kind of a unofficial movement. All the other names are covered in detail or in passing - Charles Erdman, Charles Macartney, Adoniram Judson Gordon, RA Torrey, AC Dixon, AT Pierson, and others.

Fundamentalism did play a part in its own story of compromise. The original wall of separatism that led the movement to eschew secular education, political power, and to cast even a sceptical eye (at times) to wealth and cultural elitism, would begin to crumble in the face of World War I.

At the onset of the war, the movement (broadly speaking) was hostile to Christian participation and indifferent to the fury of American patriotism that broke out as America neared its 1917 entry into the conflict. The Fundamentalists encouraged Christians not to enlist, to refuse conscription, and to reject voting. The war had nothing to do with the Church and nationalism was viewed as poison. They were attacked by mainstream (even Liberal) Christianity as subversives and even accused of being German agents. I've written elsewhere about Arthur Pink's publisher IC Herendeen based out of Central Pennsylvania. His Swengel publishing house was raided and he briefly faced charges under the Espionage Act for producing material that encouraged Christians not to support the war.

But this would change. Many Fundamentalists succumbed to the propaganda and the big shift came with the Russian Revolution and the fear of Communism. The Red Scare of the 1920's also played a significant part and the movement as a whole began to argue for cultural and political engagement - but this was limited at first. And yet it's not hard to see how after the Depression and the further perceived threat of Communist movements as well as the perceived socialist New Deal programmes of FDR - many who shared this mindset were alarmed. Then World War II happened and by the end of that period the full-fledged shift into the New Evangelical ethos was underway, fueled again by the emergence of the Cold War, McCarthyism, and all that followed. Many of today's Fundamentalists still defend McCarthy and openly espouse the narratives of the John Birch Society. Their one-time separatism and call to non-participation has been transformed into the ideology of the extreme Right.

Marsden doesn't address the argument as it extends well beyond the scope of his book, but it's often put forward that because of Fundamentalist retreat, the Christians lost the country and the culture. From 1925-1979 Christians abdicated their duty as Christian citizens and handed over the country to secularists and Leftists - or so the Dominionist narrative goes. This is self-serving revisionism at best. While many Christians eschewed politics, the numbers of those engaged was constantly growing and the Evangelical movement's rise in the late 1940's completely dashes this bogus narrative. The issue was not a total lack of interest or participation but largely one of American political division - a division today's Right-wing doesn't like to revisit and has also chosen to white-wash. The majority of conservative Christians in the South were Democrats and this reality and the questions it generates are further muddled by associations with Segregation. Because of the Civil War, pro-Southern Christians hated the Republican Party of Lincoln and the wealthy industrial interests it represented - not to mention (to many) the Liberal Theology of North that fueled everything from abolition and women's suffrage. Prohibition was also connected but that of course was championed by many Southerners. It's complicated.

But basically it comes down to this - when Lyndon Johnson sponsored civil rights legislation, voter rights, and the larger Great Society agenda in the 1960's, the exodus began. Old Southern segregationist politicians by the dozen began to migrate into the GOP and by the 1970's a figure like Jerry Falwell could finally bring together the Evangelicals of both the North and South into a political coalition. They tepidly supported Carter in 1976 but were disappointed and then threw all their efforts into electing Reagan. By this time the Evangelical movement had completely signed on with the GOP's post-war/Cold War agenda of economic neoliberalism, anti-Soviet militancy, and (due to Evangelical influence) an agenda of conservative social values which from the onset were compromised. The embrace of Reagan only amplified this. He wasn't part of any church, was divorced, and it would later emerged was heavily influenced by astrology, and yet they loved him and the compromises continued right down to Donald Trump. Not a few commentators acknowledged the embrace of Trump was the moment the movement functionally repudiated everything it had been fighting for in contrast to the Baby Boomer culture of the 1960's - so typified by their great political antagonists, the Clintons. They think they 'won', but only did so by moving the goalposts and re-defining themselves.

To understand 20th century Evangelicalism, one must probe this deeper story of its Fundamentalist roots and the way the movements split and interacted with one another. Marsden work is supremely helpful in this task.

Within these pages we encounter the rise of Carnal Christianity in connection to Holiness movements, Keswick, American Pragmatism, the Social Gospel, and chapters of Culture War that have been largely forgotten. We end the book with Fundamentalist preacher J Frank Norris murdering a political opponent in his church office, the Auburn Affirmation of 1924, the rise of popular literature criticising Fundamentalism, and finally again, the Scopes Trial.

Marsden is careful and fair in his assessments and the book is well written, though some will find the narrative labyrinthine at times. There are so many strands of thought and various movements coming together in the post-Civil War era.

Though it's touched on lightly by Marsden, once again I find the question of Industrialisation and the new urban culture is not given proper attention. There was a real social crisis taking place - one that groups like YMCA and Salvation Army were trying to address on the one hand and the Liberals from another. The world was undergoing massive change. We too live in such a moment with the technological revolution, but in some respects the changes taking place during the scope of Marsden's book were far more profound. People moved from a world that (apart from the telegraph, train, and steam revolution) was still more akin to past centuries, to a world of steel, skyscrapers, electrification, the telephone, audio recordings, the automobile, the aeroplane, and the growth of cities on a scale never seen before in history. It's hard for us to imagine how these things changed everyday life and the dynamics of the family and community - and how different it was in contrast to life in rural America. Contemporary authors speak of the profundity of urban electrification - something we now take for granted. The only comparison might be found in those of us who are of a certain age that remember life before the personal computer, the Internet, the mobile phone, and the Smartphone. Culture has been completely transformed by these innovations and they too have affected the Church and how it interacts with the world.

Usually when I tread these paths I end up also revisiting a couple of other works - books I've mentioned more than once in my various writings and essays. One is James Turner's 1986 work Without God, Without Creed- The Origins of Unbelief in America. It is an unpleasant and frustrating read to be sure but he traces out the influence of American Idealism and other intellectual trends and their interaction with Christian thought and doctrine. He convincingly demonstrates how for average, respectable, Americans who believed very much in the system under which they lived - belief in the Bible became more and more difficult and for many over time it became impossible. The forms were often retained long after the substance had been abandoned. From miracles to essential gospel concepts connected to sacrificial atonement and eternal punishment, the pragmatic, libertarian, mindset of Americans who believed in not only their freedom but of man's basic goodness, struggled with these doctrines and progressively abandoned them. And here's where it gets really interesting - after abandoning these doctrines, over time they became not only offensive but were viewed as being morally questionable. And this mindset was not just out in the secular culture, but became deeply ingrained within the churches. It helps to explain what is happening today in the various Mainline bodies and while some 'conservative' groups are breaking away, if you scratch beneath the surface you'll find these basic issues have not gone away and as such the future of these groups (the EPC, Global Methodists, ACNA, and others) is in question.

It's a challenging read dealing with heavy philosophical subjects and it weighs on me every time I revisit it but it's a dark road that needs to be travelled sometimes in order to review and understand the story.

The other work that comes to mind if Iain Murray's Evangelicalism Divided, published in 2000. Murray briefly traces the rise of theological liberalism and then interacts with the post-war Evangelical scene - dancing back and forth between America and Britain, between Evangelical leaders like Billy Graham, John Stott, Charles Colson, and figures like Francis Schaeffer and Martyn Lloyd-Jones. He deals extensively with the ecumenical movement and the interactions between Rome and Canterbury and the struggles of the Evangelical movement with Anglicanism led by figures such as JI Packer. He touches on questions of Evangelicals and academic respectability and in general the compromising spirit of the movement and how by 1994 it led to the support of the Evangelicals and Catholics Together (ECT) ecumenical symbol. By the year 2000 - things had fallen to a very low state indeed and rumour has it that Murray was rather depressed after authoring the book. It's not without its flaws and I often disagree with Murray, but it remains an indispensable work.

There are other books that could be cited to be sure and I've certainly read my share but these works were critical in terms of my formation. I remember when Murray's work was released and I eagerly devoured it and have read it through at least a dozen times since then. My head whirls when I realize it's been over twenty-five years since it first came into my hands. I still think of it as a 'newer' work.

So these two recommendations function as kind of 'book-ends' to Marsden's work. The one goes deeper into the questions and context that would give rise to theological liberalism and thus provoke the response of Fundamentalist belief. This is not to say that Fundamentalism was new in what in believed but rather the package, the ordering, the framing of theology and doctrine and certainly the style were novel. And even now there are aspects of it that remain attractive, and even while admirable on one level, it's overall effect and legacy has proven negative. At least I would argue so.

Murray's work helps to tell another chapter of the larger story of how older, basic, more Fundamental and Confessional beliefs were in turn undermined and (it could be argued) dismantled and destroyed by Evangelicalism - which itself grew out of Fundamentalism and was in part a reaction to it. The founding fathers of the Evangelical movement were concerned to combat Fundamentalist separatism and wanted a place at the table in terms of cultural debate and influence. They sought respectability and Murray is pretty convincing in demonstrating how now only did they not find that respectability, but they made numerous fatal compromises along the way. That story is all too pertinent as we watch the course of events since the time he wrote it in the year 2000. Things have come a long way since then in terms of Church movements, the Internet, and politics.

And in closing I will add, there are undoubtedly many videos available online that trace out this story and maybe they have some utility, but if you're serious about understanding this and grounding your thinking and reflection - you need to invest the time and energy in reading books like these - and maybe even reading them more than once.

See also:

https://proto-protestantism.blogspot.com/2026/07/sola-scriptura-and-spectrum-of.html